Knitting. Yarn. Fiber artistry. More knitting. Nursing school. Hospice work. Death and the dying process. Phoenix Raven's. Knitting. Yarn. Oh, and Life As An Air Force Wife.
Published on November 2, 2005 By dharmagrl In Misc

My husband reads 'Backwoods Home' magazine online fairly regularly. 

Whilst he was perusing it this morning, he came across an article by a man named Dave Duffy that I think accurately sums up the role of the government in any national disaster or catastrophy. (Link )

You can read the article in it's entireity by following the link, but I've copied and pasted some of what I felt to be the best parts.

'Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath said what I could not have said convincingly in ten thousand words: The government cannot protect you in a major emergency. It doesn’t matter whether it’s a hurricane, a terrorist attack, or a burglar breaking into your home in the dead of night. It does not matter whether it’s a Republican or Democrat in the White House. In the end, you—and only you—have the power to protect yourself and your family when everything is on the line. To assume otherwise is to dangle your family into the swirling caldron of unpredictable Nature, terrorists, and criminals.'

'you’d think from watching the TV coverage and reading all the media hysterics about Hurricane Katrina that the United States had just suffered some sort of cataclysmic failure in our political structure because the Government wasn’t there quick enough to rescue all the victims of the floods.

Huh? Does the media live in Disneyland? Of course I realize a lot of the coverage was just the left leaning media trying to make their arch enemy, President Bush, look bad. In an effort to put lefties back in power in the White House and Congress at some point in the future, they’ll gladly mislead the public into thinking Government could have and should have rescued all the victims of the hurricane and ensuing flooding.

But here’s the awful truth: If a major disaster, such as another category 4 or 5 hurricane, or a major terrorist attack with, say, a dirty bomb, occurs again, unprepared people will suffer terribly just as the unprepared people of New Orleans suffered terribly. Government, at all levels, is simply not organized (it’s run by bureaucracies, for God’s sake) or equipped to respond quickly to large emergencies.'

 

'Hurricane Katrina and the inability of Government at any level to respond in a timely, life-saving manner should set off alarm bells in our heads. If you want to protect yourself and your family, don’t follow the advice of the media or opportunistic politicians by voting for a new set of politicians and asking Government to spend billions of dollars on various projects. That won’t do it.

Take your life into your own hands and plan to take care of yourself and your family in an emergency situation. You, any only you, can become the timely power that will save your family when disaster strikes.'

 

Ne'er a truer word has been spoken, JU.  Ultimately, we are ALL responsible for our own well being and safety.  Period.  No if's, and's or but's about it.  People have GOT to start not only understanding, but enacting that philosophy.  We, as a nation, can't afford to rely on a dysfunctional, corrupt government to get us out of a bind any longer. 

I want to say that I think Hurricane Katrina taught us all that......but I honestly think that some people didn't learn a damn thing from that disaster (except that when the governments gives you 2 grand you should go get that Louis Vuitton bag you always wanted and worry about finding housing later.  I mean, FEMA's got trailers for you to live in and they'll take care of you, right? *sigh*)

What's it going to take before people sit up and take notice to what people like Mr Duffy are saying?  How many more catastrophes have to occur before people learn that they HAVE to be responsible for themselves?

 


Comments
on Nov 02, 2005
I agree, for the most part, with what you've said. There is definitely a lack of Self-Responsibility in today's society and this is especially obvious during times of crisis. If the NWS says leave the area because its going to get slammed with a storm.. You LEAVE the area. If they say you can stay, but be sure to stock up on food, you STOCK UP ON FOOD.

On the other hand, there is only so much an individual can do. "No man is an island" and we all still depend on our neighbors and society to help out when things go far beyond what an individual is capable of coping with. I will do everything I can to protect myself and my family, but if I get overwhelmed then I expect my local First Responders to help the situation. If they get overwhelmed then I expect the state Emergency management to also help. Finally, if the state's resources are overwhelmed then I expect federal assistance in handling the situation.

I don't expect the government (run by bureaucrats) to save my when the S hits the F, but I do expect it to set up teams (local, state and even federal) that are free of the bureaucrocracy and have the skills to materials to help.
on Nov 02, 2005
Good article. The purpose of the government is to protect our rights, not always us, per se. It's created by us and we have the power and ability to alter and/or abolish the government.

I also agree with you, Voyager, that we need to help each other as human beings and, to an extent, have an obligation to help those around us and work as a unified nation.

~Sarah
on Nov 02, 2005

protect our rights, not always us, per se

Actually, yes it is.  But defense against human enemies, not mother nature.

on Nov 02, 2005
So true Dharma, I agree with him totally. And Hurricane Katrina hasn't taught many people much if anything. Now it's back to business as usual for a lot of folks, including the government. Even though they're still taking care of people caught in the disasters.

I thought the same thing when Katrina hit then Wilma and now that there is talk of the Bird Flu....we will be in big trouble! I don't think our country is prepared at all to handle a major disaster. All we can do, and I agee with Voyerger that one can only do so much. We will all no matter how prepared we make ourselves still need help, and I'm not talking monetarily, if disaster does strike!
on Nov 02, 2005
I hear ya Dharma! Link

on Nov 02, 2005
Kudos to Dave Duffy, Backwoods Magazine, "D" and You for bringing Mr. Duffy's words to our eyes!!!

It's sad that, once We the People think we've conned the government into doing something "for" us, the next step we take is to quit doing it ourselves, then insist the government do it for us.

Emergency Management is about REDUCING the threat and effects of emergencies and disasters. In some cases (like many manmade emergencies) a few changes in habits and regulations can all but remove a threat from our lives. Unfortunately though, life was never meant to be emergency free, and no amount of whining, wishing, taxing or even well-planned mitigation and preparedness can (or even should) change that fact.

As for New Orleans and Katrina, the biggest disaster was the press. When all their rhetoric and rumor-mongering boiled down to cold hard fact, New Orleans looks like any other major disaster... not the several hundred billion dollar cash cow Nagin hoped his incompetence would muster.

The next disaster there won't be the years and years of disease and toxic water and air.. it will be the bottomless bog of money that will go everywhere except the people who lost everything. After all, New Orleans means Mardis Gras, not homes...
on Nov 03, 2005

"No man is an island" and we all still depend on our neighbors and society to help out when things go far beyond what an individual is capable of coping with

I agree with that, but.......it looked like NOBODY down in NO was prepared.

I also agree with you, Voyager, that we need to help each other as human beings and, to an extent, have an obligation to help those around us and work as a unified nation.

Ideally that's what would happen.  Unfortunately, katrina bought out the worst of certain sections of the population, and the media was there to see it all and broadcast it around the world.  Some of Kanye West's "people" were looking out for no one but themselves.  Some of them deomonstrated not a 'we can overcome if we work together' attitude but a 'screw you, I'm looking out for me and me alone'....and sadly, that's what the rest of the world saw.  That's why you had people like Phoenixboi asking his american friends just what the fuck we were living like.

 

Hurricane Katrina hasn't taught many people much if anything. Now it's back to business as usual for a lot of folks, including the government

Sadly, this too is true.

Looks like folks didn't learn much from Katrina, the DAY after Wilma hit, thousands and thousands of people were standing in line for water and ice, and bitching loudly about how long they had been waiting.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!  Oh, the stupidity of some people makes me wonder how in the hell they make it through the day without hurting themselves or someone else.

If you're too damn stupid (or lazy) to put back a three day water supply for every member of your household, PERISH OF THIRST, YOU SHOULDNT HAVE BRED IN THE FIRST PLACE.

I'm probably going to get crucified for this, but I'm going to say it anyway. 

When I lived up in the Black Hills of South Dakota, there were a fair amount of forest and prairie fires.  The local Lakota Indians believed that such fires were natural and were the earth's way of cleansing herself. 

Apply that philosophy to the natural disasters that have hit the US recently.  Survival of the fittest, perhaps?

I hear ya Dharma!

I knew YOU would, Shovel.  That's because you're smart, see.

It's sad that, once We the People think we've conned the government into doing something "for" us, the next step we take is to quit doing it ourselves, then insist the government do it for us

Exactly! 

on Nov 04, 2005
I think a couple of you have the right intention but may still be a little misguided. While no man is an island, if one man prepared himself and then 10 men prepared themselves, then 100 men, then 1000, well, you get the picture. My point is: If everyone took care of themselves just a little bit more and prepared just a little bit more and perhaps had listened to the government before the disaster just a little bit more, things may have turned out different and instead of the media disaster that is was, it would have shown the world that Americans stick together and can/will survive.

As far as the gov't helping, I agree that it should help. BUT, it should not solve every individual's problem. It should focus on rebuilding the infrastructure. Individuals should be focusing on their lives. The gov't doesn't (and can't) work miracles.

All I'm saying is WE all have a responsibility to OURSELVES. I would help anyone else, any way I could but you better believe my family WOULD NOT do without so I could help someone else.

You can also bet your ass that I'm gonna do everything I can to protect me and mine.