Knitting. Yarn. Fiber artistry. More knitting. Nursing school. Hospice work. Death and the dying process. Phoenix Raven's. Knitting. Yarn. Oh, and Life As An Air Force Wife.
...setting a person up for failure.
Published on August 17, 2005 By dharmagrl In Misc

*this is rant.  it's only a rant.   if you don't like rants, or don't want to listen to my ranting, you should go away now*

I'm so sick of hearing that annoying 'you can be anything you want to be if you just try hard enough' phrase being touted around.

It's simply not true.  If a person has an IQ of 77 they're hardly likely to become a neurosurgeon, now are they?  It has nothing to do with trying hard, it's more a question of simply not being physically or mentally able. 

It seem to me that using that message is setting some kids up for failure.  When little Johnny fails to be an doctor because he simply isn't smart enough, he's going to blame himself for not trying hard enough. 

I understand the parents want their children to better themselves.  I want to see my children not have to struggle like I did, I'd like to see them make something of themselves....but I'd be just as happy with them being plumbers or beauticians as I would attorneys and pharmacists.   Yes, I want them to be all that they can be, but I want them to do it within their capabilities.  Our Jake, for example, isn't a 'book smart' child, but when it comes to cooking....but that boy's a natural in the kitchen and can cook up a (supervised) storm, and he's only 9.  His brother is a straight A grade student, but he burns toast and can't boil an egg.

Each child should be encouraged to be all that they can be, yes....WITHIN THEIR CAPABILITIES.  Telling a 'D' student who's busting his ass to make that grade that he can get a PhD in political science if he just tries hard enough is just setting him up for failure.


Comments (Page 2)
2 Pages1 2 
on Aug 18, 2005
ps - Thanks for sticking that dang Blue's Clues song in my head.


Oh, and you're welcome...
on Aug 18, 2005
Great FANTASTIC job. Here's a cookie (Insightful)

That does not mean that my nephew with DS is going to be a doctor, but I will not write off him have a productive life either.

You don't get it. Productive life doesn't equal unlimited potential/abilities.

Too many kids are told they "can do anything they want to" and feel as though there is something wrong with them if they can't achieve it. We need to be reminding kids that everyone has individualized interests, talents and abilities. Setting sights too high or in the wrong area is a good way to feel overwhelmed and incapable.

I studied Korean from 6 am to 4 pm with only an hour for lunch (and i usually studied through that), then 3-4 hours of homework everynight, tutoring, flashcards, tapes, you name it. I felt like a complete idiot for 2 years of my life. I had never failed so miserably at anything in my life. When people told me I wasn't "trying hard enough" or that I "wasn't taking it seriously" I wanted to scream. What more could I do? I cried at night, had nightmares (in Korean), paniced in class when I did know the answer, and felt pathetic and stupid compared to those around me. I was miserable.

As a medic, I "got" it. I understood the how and why of everything. I stumped my instructors when I surpassed them and started asking hard questions. I felt a million times better about myself and my abilities. My self esteem came back and the world was a much better place.

Turns out, I have a learning disorder (never knew it) It's based on my ability to recall things I hear. For some reason, I don't remember things that are based on an aural memory. I ahve been able to work around it so easily my whole life, that I never knew it until I was tested a few years ago. Now the failing grades in my Korean listening class make more sense. I'm still productive and smart, but in certian areas, my abilities will never reach past a certain point, NO MATTER HOW HARD I TRY OR HOW MUCH I WORK AT IT.
2 Pages1 2